Few transfers encapsulate the volatility of modern football like Antony’s journey from Ajax prodigy to Manchester United misfit. Once hailed as the solution to the Red Devils’ long-standing right-wing woes, the Brazilian’s £82 million move in 2022 now stands as a cautionary tale about the pressures facing elite prospects. As the 24-year-old attempts to resurrect his career through a January 2025 loan move to Real Betis, both player and club find themselves at a crossroads.
For Antony, it’s about proving he belongs among Europe’s top talents. For Betis, an opportunity to acquire a high-profile talent at reduced cost—provided he can rediscover the form that made him indispensable in Amsterdam.
Antony’s Bid for Redemption at Real Betis
Since joining Real Betis on a six-month loan in January 2025, Antony has shown glimpses of the form that once made him one of Europe’s most sought-after wingers. The 24-year-old Brazilian, whose Manchester United career stalled amid inconsistent performances, has started twice for Betis, scoring once and earning back-to-back Player of the Match awards.
His debut goal—a composed finish against Celta Vigo—highlighted his technical ability, though Betis ultimately lost the match 3-2. Club CEO Ramón Alarcón has openly discussed the possibility of a permanent transfer, citing “very good chemistry” with United and praising Antony’s adaptability. With Betis sitting 11th in La Liga, Antony’s resurgence could bolster their push for European qualification while offering him a platform to rebuild his reputation.
These early performances have sparked discussions about a potential permanent move, with Betis CEO Ramón Alarcón expressing interest in retaining Antony beyond his loan period.
A Mixed Legacy at Old Trafford
Antony’s £82 million move to Manchester United in August 2022—the third-most expensive signing in the club’s history—came with lofty expectations. His debut season included moments of promise:
- 8 goals in 42 appearances across all competitions.
- A debut goal against Arsenal and a strike in the Manchester derby.
- A match-winning Europa League goal against Barcelona in February 2023, voted United’s Goal of the Season.
However, his output dwindled sharply. By the 2024/25 season, he had fallen out of favour under successive managers, failing to register a single Premier League start before his loan departure. Technical limitations, including a reliance on his left foot and struggles in one-on-one situations, drew criticism. United’s current manager, Rúben Amorim, reportedly sees no future for him at Old Trafford.
Early Promise and Unmet Expectations
Before joining United, Antony was a key figure at Ajax under Erik ten Hag, contributing 25 goals and 22 assists in 82 games and winning two Eredivisie titles. His direct style, close control, and ability to cut inside from the right wing made him a standout in Ten Hag’s system. United’s decision to invest heavily in him reflected a belief that he could solve their long-standing issues on the right flank.
Yet the transition to the Premier League proved challenging. While he occasionally delivered moments of brilliance—such as his FA Cup quarter-final winner against Liverpool in March 2024—his overall impact was inconsistent. A lack of tactical flexibility and defensive contributions further limited his opportunities, culminating in his January 2025 loan move.
